The S&P 500, the Nasdaq Composite index, and the Wilshire 5000 index all scored record highs this week, purportedly stirred by comments from Fed Chair Jerome Powell during his semi-annual testimony to Congress. This was despite the fact that Powell was clear during his testimony that he was not sending signals about any rate cut and that more good data was needed prior to any rate cut. Still, CME’s FedWatch continued to price in 50 basis points of easing this year and a 72% chance for a 25-basis-point cut at the September meeting.
In January, the consensus was expecting eight Fed rate cuts, and this dropped to two. In short, rate cut expectations have fallen well short of earlier forecasts, and in our view, it is evident that Fed rate cuts are not a driving force of the 2024 stock market. Earnings expectations linked to AI growth have been the catalyst for a number of technology stocks, and this has kept the popular averages moving higher.
Liquidity
The second quarter earnings season begins this week, and good earnings results may be a necessary factor for further gains. Shares of The Goldman Sachs Group, Inc. (GS – $472.83), JPMorgan Chase & Co. (JPM – $207.63), Citigroup Inc. (C – $66.55), and Wells Fargo & Company (WFC – $59.88) rallied ahead of earnings releases expected from the latter three later this week. Bank stocks may have been boosted by Powell’s comments to Congress indicating that regulators should seek additional feedback on the contentious “Basel III Endgame” proposal which would change risk guidelines and hike bank capital requirements. He added that a re-proposal was essential given the significant changes that would be imposed and that this would take time. Since Powell’s comments were in line with what the major banks had been asking for, this may have sparked the rally. Nonetheless, gains in banking stocks are always a welcomed factor since it is a favorable sign for the economy and the stock market. But if these gains are to be sustained, earnings results need to be in line with, or better than, expectations.
We noticed that liquidity in the banking sector is at record highs, which is a bit surprising since the Fed has been shrinking its balance sheet. After the mini bank crisis in March 2023, the Federal Reserve returned to its policy of quantitative tightening and since the April 2022 peak of $9.01 trillion, the Fed’s balance sheet is down $1.7 trillion to $7.27 trillion. This decline includes a $1.22 trillion decrease in US Treasury securities, a $404 billion drop in mortgage-backed securities, and a $115.5 billion reduction in loans. See page 3.
But despite this shrinkage in the Fed’s balance sheet, liquidity in the banking sector remains healthy. Near the end of June, demand deposits, retail money market funds, and small-time deposits were at, or near, record highs. “Other liquid deposits” appear to be most sensitive to the Fed’s balance sheet and have declined $3.5 trillion since their April 2022 peak. However, total assets at all commercial banks were $25.51 trillion at the end of June, an all-time high. See page 4. Liquidity is a necessary ingredient for any bull market, and it appears that liquidity remains robust despite the Fed’s tightening policies.
The Economy
June’s employment report was reassuring for investors since it was in line with the consensus. The establishment survey reported 206,000 new jobs and the household survey showed a small 0.1 increase in the unemployment rate to 4.1%. June’s total employment of 158.6 million jobs was a new record. The year-over-year growth rate eased to 1.67%, just under the long-term growth rate of 1.7%, but still healthy. Meanwhile, the household survey continues to be weaker than the establishment survey. Total employment of 161.2 million was below the record 161.9 million set in November 2023 and the year-over-year growth rate was 0.12% YOY, fractionally below May’s 0.23% YOY pace. Over the last six months, the growth rate in the household survey has been trending toward zero which could be significant and a negative sign for the overall economy. Year-over-year declines in total jobs have been one of the best predictors of an economic recession, as seen in the chart on page 5. Neither survey is there yet, but upcoming job releases will be important.
The good news in June’s jobs report was the steady 4% YOY increase in average hourly earnings. This means real hourly earnings grew slightly more than inflation, which is currently at 3.3%. The same was true of weekly earnings, which rose 3.7% YOY to $1012.69. See page 6.
Last week’s ISM manufacturing indices showed broad-based weakness. The ISM service indices, released Wednesday, were surprisingly soft with seven of ten indices coming in below the breakeven 50 level, and nine of ten indices declining for the month. Only the imports index rose from 42.8 to 44.0, but this was still below the 50 neutral level. Business activity was one of the weakest segments of the service industry survey, falling from 61.2 to 49.6. A key takeaway from the ISM surveys was that both employment indices were below 50 in June. Another sign of possible job weakness. See page 7.
Technicals
The Nasdaq Composite index and the S&P 500 recorded all-time highs again this week led by big-cap technology stocks. However, the Dow Jones Industrial Average is 1.8% below its record high on May 17, 2024 and the Russell 2000 index remains 16.9% below its high of 2442.74 made on November 8, 2021. The Russell is still trading below its 50-day and 100-day moving averages this week and the DJIA is trading slightly above its two moving averages. This is not a broad-based advance. See page 10.
The 25-day up/down volume oscillator is minus 0.82, still in neutral territory, but retreating toward the uptrend in place in this oscillator since the October 2022 low. What this minus 0.82 reading means is that while the S&P 500 and the Nasdaq Composite index continued to score a series of all-time highs, over the last 25 trading sessions there has been slightly more volume in declining stocks than in advancing stocks. This is a bad omen for the market. Bull markets tend to stay overbought for long periods of time in this indicator – a sign of sustained buying pressure. The oscillator was last in overbought territory for four consecutive trading days between May 17 and May 22. Since a minimum of five consecutive trading days in overbought is required to confirm a new high, this indicator has not yet confirmed any of the new highs made in the S&P 500 index and Dow Jones Industrial Average since January. See page 11. Conversely, the NYSE cumulative advance/decline line did make a new high on July 8, 2024. But while advancing stocks may define the trend of the market, advancing volume defines the strength of the trend. In short, the current rally is falling short of being confirmed. This is worth noting since at current prices the S&P 500 is trading at 25.1 times trailing and 21.3 times forward earnings. Both are extremely rich. See page 8.
PLEASE NOTE: Unless otherwise stated, the firm and any affiliated person or entity 1) either does not own any, or owns less than 1%, of the outstanding shares of any public company mentioned, 2) does not receive, and has not within the past 12 months received, investment banking compensation or other compensation from any public company mentioned, and 3) does not expect within the next three months to receive investment banking compensation or other compensation from any public company mentioned. The firm does not currently make markets in any public securities.
