Ironically, as President Trump’s April 2 target date for implementing tariffs approaches, investors are beginning to understand Trump’s negotiating process, and the fear of a tariff war appears to be subsiding. In sum, tariffs may, or may not, be implemented; it depends upon the flexibility of the export country, but if this were a card game, the US already has a better hand. At least for the moment, equity prices seem to be stabilizing.
It is not a surprise, and should not go unnoticed, that officials from both the European Union and India are meeting with US trade officials this week to avoid steep tariffs next week. This has been the goal – to get our trading partners to the negotiating table in earnest. According to Reuters, India is open to cutting tariffs on more than half of US imports worth $23 billion in the first phase of a trade deal that the two nations are negotiating. It should not be a surprise that the overwhelming angst regarding tariffs since President Trump came into office has been exaggerated and misplaced. The real fear regarding the strength of the US economy in 2025 should be on how the economy will fare once the massive fiscal stimulus implemented throughout the four-year Biden administration disappears. This has been our worry; because as fiscal stimulus has been fading, consumption has already been weakening, and 70% of US GDP is driven by the consumer. There is a potential counterbalance; but the question is whether or not Congress can, or will, soon pass a comprehensive tax reform bill that will help support the average household by lowering taxes. Republicans are quickly discovering that a slim majority in both houses of Congress does not guarantee success in passing legislation. Therefore, there is risk to the consumer and to the economy this year.
Another, but longer term concern we have is the recent disclosure that a sophisticated Chinese network is trying to recruit newly fired, and we assume angry and disenfranchised, federal employees. Max Lesser, a senior analyst for emerging threats at the Washington-based think tank Foundation for Defense of Democracies, said some companies placing recruitment ads were “part of a broader network of fake consulting and headhunting firms targeting former government employees and AI researchers.” Lesser uncovered the network and shared his research with Reuters ahead of his publication. He said the campaign follows “well-established” techniques used by previous Chinese intelligence operations. This type of recruitment is not really new; however, in the current Washington DC political environment that is steeped in partisan anger and cynicism, these fired workers and the US in general, could become particularly vulnerable to Chinese espionage.
The S&P 500 is down 8% from its recent peak, down 1.8% year-to-date, and is currently on track for its first quarterly loss since June 2023. However, a correction was long overdue. Moody’s rating agency reported that the United States’ fiscal health deteriorated since it last lowered its outlook on the AAA rating in November 2023, and the US is on track for a continued multiyear decline as budget deficits widen and debt becomes less affordable. Federal debt has been our major concern for 2025. Meanwhile, more dismal news came from consumer confidence surveys.
The Conference Board’s consumer confidence index made headlines because it fell from a revised 101.1 (previously 98.3) in February to 92.9 in March, its lowest reading since January 2021. The present situation index also declined, but remains well above its long-term average. The story was in the expectations index which fell 9.6 points to 65.2, its lowest reading in 12 years. See page 7. But note that the Conference Board has been systematically revising previous monthly readings higher. More importantly, as we noted last week when analyzing the University of Michigan survey, sentiment is swayed by political bias and in the current environment by Democratic pessimism. This suggests that much like the bias seen in past presidential-election polls, sentiment indices may not be a reliable predictor of economic outcomes. In our view, retail sales are the better benchmark for measuring consumer strength or weakness. Note that March retail sales data will be released on April 16.
Housing data for February was mixed but continues to show weakness. Seasonally adjusted existing home sales were 4.26 million (SAAR) in February, down 1.2% YOY; however, this was the first YOY decline in five months. Seasonally adjusted new home sales were 676,000 in February, up 5.1% YOY, after being unchanged in January. The median price of an existing single-family home was $402,500, up 3.7%, but rising at a decelerating pace. The median price of a new single-family home was $414,500, down 1.5% YOY, continuing the slow decline seen for most of the last two years. See page 3. The discrepancy between existing and new home price trends has existed since the second half of 2023 and the weakness in new construction may be a result of higher prices and excess capacity. Over the last 50 years existing home prices and retail sales have been highly correlated, so it is encouraging that both existing home prices and retail sales have remained positive and stable. See page 4. Again, upcoming retail sales reports will be an important barometer of consumer strength.
The NAHB single-family housing market index has been declining since the end of March 2024; but the good news is that housing affordability is slowly improving as incomes rise and home prices ease. The index of median existing home prices versus personal income per capita has dropped from “expensive” to “normal” in recent months. Unfortunately, the median home price relative to median household income remains in the “expensive” range which suggests that mid-range housing prices may decline further in coming quarters. See page 5.
One positive for the real estate market is that the Federal Reserves’ newly revised household debt service ratios show the mortgage debt service ratio has stayed low, stable, and healthy over the last 18 months. In the fourth quarter of 2024, the mortgage debt ratio dipped from 5.83% to 5.77%. Conversely, the consumer debt service ratio rose from 5.48% to 5.51%, and is up from a pandemic low of 4.31% in 1Q21. See page 6. Recent consumer credit card data suggest this ratio continued to move higher in the first quarter of this year.
At the March 13, 2025 lows, the peak to trough declines in the S&P 500, Dow Jones Industrial Average, the Nasdaq Composite index, and the Russell 2000 index were 10.1%, 9.3%, 14.2%, and 18.4%, respectively. Not only did the S&P 500 appear to stabilize after a 10% correction, but the Nasdaq Composite index rebounded off its 2022-2025 uptrend line and the Russell 2000 index bounced off its pivotal 2000 resistance/support level. These were all important levels of support, and the bounce off these levels makes it likely that the “fear of tariffs” decline has run its course. However, most market lows are retested and this low may be no exception. See page 10. The 25-day up/down volume oscillator is at minus 0.59 this week, neutral, and relatively unchanged for the week. However, it was significant that the equity market rallied after this indicator reached a level of negative 1.84 on March 13, its lowest level since the market weakness seen in December/January. And finally, last week’s AAII survey showed bull/bear percentages of 21.6%/58.1%. These numbers continue to exceed the bull/bear split of 20/50 which is rare and favorable. The AAII 8-week bull/bear index is minus 23.6% and the most positive since November 2022. All in all, the technical backdrop of the equity market suggests bearishness has run its course.
Gail Dudack